LOS ANGELES — Xavier Becerra and Steve Hilton went at it in Los Angeles this week, giving California voters their clearest preview yet of what the race to replace Gov. Gavin Newsom is going to look like when two people who fundamentally disagree about everything share a stage.
Related: The Replanting Race: Why California's Weather Window to Regrow a Burned Forest Is Closing · The Seed That Can't Wait: Inside California's Race Against Fire Season to Replant What Burned
Wire reports billed it as a duel over "California's future." Becerra, the former state attorney general and U.S. health secretary under President Joe Biden, squared off against Hilton, the conservative commentator and ex-Fox News host whose entire campaign is basically a sustained complaint about Sacramento's regulatory appetite. Details of the exchange are thin, but both camps are clearly treating the Los Angeles media market like a proving ground.
For voters, it's a preview of the ideological brawl likely to run through next year. Becerra has spent decades inside Democratic officialdom: Congress, the state's top law enforcement post, a Cabinet seat in Washington. Hilton is selling himself as the outsider, leaning hard into voter frustration over high costs, homelessness, and businesses packing up for friendlier states. Neither of those stories is new to California politics. Neither has a clean ending yet.
The timing matters. Any incoming governor inherits a full inbox. A federal judge this week blocked California's recycling symbol law for plastic containers, a real sting to one of Sacramento's signature environmental pushes and a reminder that California's regulatory ambitions have a habit of colliding with federal courts. Meanwhile, state lawmakers are weighing a bill that would let ordinary citizens sue some of the world's largest companies directly. Business groups are already howling about it, which is unsurprising in a state a lot of corporations already treat as hostile territory.
Both fights, regulation and litigation, are shaping up as proxy battles for the governor's race itself. Hilton's pitch is that California's regulatory instincts, good intentions and all, have chased jobs and residents to other states. Becerra built his reputation as attorney general by suing the first Trump administration over 100 times, mostly on environmental and consumer protection grounds. He is not going to suddenly start arguing that Sacramento should back off.
The backdrop goes beyond policy. In Los Angeles, an advisor to Mayor Karen Bass is under scrutiny after pocketing $577,000 on an airport deal while separately consulting for the mayor's office without pay, according to wire reports. That is exactly the kind of story Hilton's campaign was made for. In Chula Vista, the City Council voted itself a hefty pay raise, which landed about as well as you'd expect in a city where residents are grinding through the same affordability crisis candidates are campaigning on statewide.
Public safety isn't giving anyone a break either. A wildfire threatened homes in Santa Clarita as a dangerous heat wave bore down on Southern California, a fresh reminder of the emergency-management demands that come with the job. A pedestrian was killed in a triple hit-and-run in Long Beach. A person was found dead on the steps of Los Angeles City Hall after falling from the 26th floor, according to an internal memo cited in wire reports. In San Francisco Bay, one person died and three remained missing after a boat sank near Alcatraz Island. None of it connects directly to the governor's race, but taken together it sketches out exactly the daily chaos whoever wins will be expected to manage.
Becerra comes in with decades of name recognition and the institutional relationships that go with a long career in elected and appointed office. Hilton has a media platform and an outsider's pitch that genuinely resonates with voters tired of one-party Sacramento. Wire reports didn't detail specific policy commitments from the Los Angeles event, and CAL WIRE could not independently confirm additional specifics beyond what has circulated publicly.
What's clear: this race is shaping up as a referendum on questions California has been arguing about for years. How hard should the state push on business and environmental regulation? How should its cities actually be run? And how much patience do voters have left for the way things are? The recycling ruling and the citizen-suit proposal both cut straight to that debate, testing where California's authority ends and federal courts begin.
With the primary field still filling in, the Becerra-Hilton exchange in Los Angeles is not the last of its kind. But it set an early marker for the lines that will define the next governor's race, one that will play out against a backdrop of wildfires, heat waves, city hall scandals, and legal fights that show no sign of cooling off before anyone casts a vote.